Risk Update

Four Canadian Law Firms Hacked, Law Firm Facing Lawsuit for Representation of Hacked Client, New York State Bar on AI Ethics for Lawyers, Florida Lawyer AI Ethics Opinion Seeking Comments

Posted on

“How hackers broke into four of Canada’s top law firms, stole client files and caused chaos” —

  • “One week ago, lawyers at Canada’s top firms received urgent calls from their IT departments about a critical software update or an expired password. The agents were happy to stay on the phone and help. Even to a skeptic, the calls could seem legitimate. They were often placed through Microsoft Teams, appearing to come from internal IT employees, or they were phone calls from the IT department’s number.”
  • “The reality: Hackers were on the other end, spamming Canadian lawyers en masse.”
  • “The tactic the hackers used is called vishing, short for voice phishing – and it worked. At least four companies were broken into, all among the country’s most prestigious law firms: McCarthy Tétrault LLP, Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLP, Bennett Jones LLP and Borden Ladner Gervais LLP.”
  • “The extent of the damage is still being assessed, but the fallout is already immense. Law firms market themselves as trusted advisers, and the nature of their work means they store sensitive files on their servers. These include non-public corporate information, communication between client and counsel, and their clients’ tax, financial or health records.”
  • “Because so much sensitive information is potentially exposed – at McCarthy Tétrault, 31,000 files were stolen, according to a source directly involved – some clients are extremely concerned, but so far remain in the dark. Lawyers at the hacked firms have been told which clients were affected, but specific details are often still coming, according to four sources and communication reviewed by The Globe and Mail.”
  • “There’s also a fear of more breaches to come. Hackers are increasingly targeting law firms, and the Canadian hack proves even the largest firms with the most sophisticated technology can’t always ward them off. What the top firms spend on hacking defences would likely exceed the annual revenues of scores of smaller boutiques across Canada that specialize in practice areas such as employment and family law.”
  • “Across the four firms that were breached, at least seven employees granted the hackers access to internal files, according to The Globe’s reporting and confirmed by the respective firms. McCarthy Tétrault had four employee accounts compromised; Bennett Jones had two; Davies had one. It is unclear how many users were compromised at BLG.”
  • “The depth of the breaches varied. At Bennett Jones, the firm’s document management system, used to protect client legal files and work product, was not affected, the firm said Friday. Its accounting system was also unaffected.”
  • “‘The compromised information included reports on revenue from clients; for certain clients, general descriptions of our mandates for them were also involved and as we identify those clients, we will contact them directly,’ Bennett Jones said in a statement.”
  • “At BLG, an internal investigation confirmed that ‘certain files, including files related to clients, were accessed by an unauthorised third party,’ the firm said Friday in a statement.”
  • “On Thursday, McCarthy Tétrault said a third party ‘gained access to certain files, including information relating to clients,’ while Davies said Thursday it identified ‘the compromise of information from one account.’ McCarthy Tétrault was hacked on Oct. 22 and Davies was hacked on Oct. 23.”
  • “In Canada, law firms and IT departments are working together to understand how the hackers got access to confidential data, what to do to help clients and how to ensure it doesn’t happen again.”

“The Next Target for Data Breach Lawsuits – Law Firms That Represent Breached Parties” —

  • “Imagine a company gets hacked and hires a law firm to manage the response. The lawyers coordinate the forensic investigation, determine which notification laws apply, and advise management about what to disclose and when. Months later, the notices arrive. The affected individuals sue the company and add its lawyers as defendants. Their theory is that counsel helped keep them in the dark when an earlier warning might have allowed them to protect themselves.”
  • “In this hypothetical, nobody hacked the law firm. The alleged wrongdoing is the firm’s handling of its client’s breach. That is a materially different claim from the increasingly familiar allegation that a law firm failed to secure personal information on its own systems. It also presents a much harder question about the person to whom the lawyer owed a duty.”
  • “Recent litigation makes the distinction particularly important. The proposed class action against Austin-based Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson concerns the firm’s own alleged data breach and failure to provide notice. The case is Lowry v. Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson, LLP, filed October 27, 2026, in the Western District of Texas. It is not evidence that a court has recognized a consumer’s malpractice claim against counsel for a separately breached company.”
  • “This is fundamentally different from a lawsuit alleging that the firm itself leaked or breached a duty to protect data it held. For example, Todd Garvin filed a proposed class action against Dill Dill Stonbraker & Hutchings on October 27, 2026. The firm’s public notice describes unauthorized access to information in its own systems during October and November 2025, a June 1, 2026 determination that personal information may have been affected, and an October 22 notice.”
  • “The more consequential question is whether plaintiffs can move from suing lawyers as custodians of compromised data to suing them as advisers to the entity that suffered the compromise. There is substantial precedent for the first category. I have not identified a reported merits decision establishing a general duty running from outside breach counsel to every individual affected by the client’s breach merely because counsel advised the client about notification.”
  • “A breach-response engagement ordinarily makes the affected company the client. Counsel’s job is to understand the facts, explain the applicable law, recommend a lawful response, and give the client enough information to make informed decisions. Model Rule 1.4 describes that obligation in terms of communication with the client. A customer whose records were stolen does not become a client of the company’s lawyers simply because those lawyers discuss the customer’s information.”
  • “Other jurisdictions reach the issue through attorney immunity as well as privity. In Haynes and Boone, LLP v. NFTD, LLC, the Texas Supreme Court held that its attorney-immunity defense can extend to legal work outside litigation in an adversarial setting. The inquiry concerns the kind of work performed, including whether it uses a lawyer’s professional skills in representing the client. The court remanded for application of that standard; it did not declare every act by a lawyer immune. The later appellate decision found that the defendants had not conclusively established the defense on the record presented. Neither decision involved a breach response, but both warn against treating all activity undertaken by a law firm as legally interchangeable.”
  • “There are equally important limits on the defense. A firm that receives and stores personal information may incur obligations arising from that conduct. The absence of an attorney-client relationship with the affected individual does not necessarily answer an ordinary data-security claim. A plaintiff must identify the applicable duty, and the firm must address the conduct actually challenged.”
  • “The Bryan Cave litigation illustrates the distinction. Employees of Mondelez sued after personal information held by the company’s law firm was exposed in a breach of the firm’s systems. In June 2024, a federal court allowed negligence claims against both the company and the law firm to proceed, reasoning in part from Illinois’s statutory requirement for reasonable data-security measures. The order states: ‘Plaintiffs’ negligence claims survive in both consolidated actions.’ That was a pleading-stage ruling, not a finding of negligence. The litigation subsequently moved into settlement proceedings. It remains a useful example of a claim concerning counsel’s custody of nonclients’ information, rather than a holding that the firm’s legal advice created a professional duty to those nonclients.”
  • “Similarly, the law firm of Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP advised Delta Dental beneficiaries that it obtained their information while representing Delta Dental and that files on Orrick’s network were compromised. The firm was sued by the data subjects for breaching their privacy.”
  • “What makes the Colorado case different is that the plaintiffs allege that they were harmed because of the advice the law firm gave to their own client, and their client’s following that advice. A different approach might have been for the class action plaintiffs to sue the entity that failed to timely notify them, and then for that company to sue their lawyers for malpractice.”
  • “This raises the stakes for both lawyers and data breach subjects – as well as for insurance companies representing both. Law firms may be more reluctant to take on high-stakes breach cases, and it injects a good deal of self-interest into the privileged relationship. For plaintiffs, the serious question is whether counsel assumed or violated a legally recognized obligation to the affected individual. For defense counsel, the serious question is whether the challenged act was legal representation, data handling, or a separate undertaking. Linebarger’s own alleged breach belongs in that analysis as a comparison, not as proof that breach advisers owe a malpractice duty to their clients’ customers. The next complaint may name the breach coach. It will still have to explain why that coach owed this plaintiff a duty.”

“New York State Bar Association Releases In-Depth Guidelines To Advise Attorneys on Ethical Use of AI” —

  • “Guidelines on artificial intelligence approved by the New York State Bar Association will help avoid the unauthorized practice of law, ensure that legal decisions are in human hands, and reduce bias in legal proceedings.”
  • “On Saturday, the New York State Bar Association’s governing body, the House of Delegates, adopted the report ‘Legal Ethics Guidelines for Lawyers’ Use of Artificial Intelligence.'”
  • “‘Generative AI is indelibly changing the practice of law. As part of our mission to be the leading voice for the legal profession, we are providing clear guidelines on the use of AI tools as a resource so attorneys can use AI responsibly and ethically in their practices,’ said Taa Grays, president of the New York State Bar Association. ‘The guidelines can help attorneys avoid possible perils of using AI including inadvertently practicing law in a jurisdiction where they are not licensed or failing to notify clients or the courts of AI use.'”
  • “The association is urging attorneys who use AI tools to check that the results do not reflect biased input from training data, design and deployment. There is concern that an AI can replicate already-existing systemic inequities – like if its training material uses sentencing information with racial disparities. This is especially relevant if the tool is being used in a way that could affect a person’s rights, access, opportunity, or treatment.”
  • “The report also advises attorneys who use AI that they may charge fees for time spent verifying an AI tool’s output, but not for learning how to use it. It is important to keep fees reasonable and disclose specific charges to clients. In addition, acquiring an AI tool is an overhead expense – so its cost may not be billed to a client, unless it is for a service specially incurred for that case.”
  • “Attorneys are also responsible for carefully supervising non-lawyers and vendors who use AI tools. While the New York Rules of Professional Conduct do not specifically address AI-generated legal work, association guidelines extrapolate that an attorney is still responsible for ensuring that a non-lawyer’s work is up to standards – even if the ‘non-lawyer’ is an AI tool or system.”
  • “The report also covers:”
    • “Conflicts of interest from a tool using data that pertains to a party in a case.”
    • “Notifying all parties when using AI for recording and summaries.”
    • “Disclosing the use of AI for court submissions – a policy many courts already have in place.”
    • Reviewing the output of agentic AI systems – tools that are designed to complete a task or accomplish a specific goal without human input.”
  • “Vivian Wesson, executive vice president, general counsel, and chief compliance officer of The Board of Pensions of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), serves as chair of the Committee on Artificial Intelligence and Emerging Technologies, which authored the report.”
  • “‘While technology keeps evolving, it is important to still follow the ethical principles of the law,’ said Wesson. ‘Our committee developed this report to aid attorneys who are using AI tools and systems to enhance their practices. We aim to help lawyers utilize the technology while fulfilling their responsibility to their clients, the courts, and the administration of justice.'”
  • Document (including its AI-generated cover image) available: here.

“Lawyers offer recommendations on proposed AI ethics opinion” —

  • “A Florida Bar committee’s proposed advisory opinion regarding artificial intelligence is generating suggestions from a handful of attorneys, most of whom are eager for more guidance.”
  • “Although a draft is not yet available, the notice advised that it may cover lawyers’ use of agentic AI tools; the use of artificial intelligence tools to record, transcribe, and summarize communications; guidance to clients regarding their use of artificial intelligence tools; and updates to guidance provided in Florida Ethics Opinion 24-1.”
  • “Gainesville lawyer Nathan Nevins, one of eight attorneys who submitted comments as of November 3, is the only commenter opposed to most lawyers’ use of the technology. A partner with Sunshine State Probate, Nevins is board certified in wills, trusts and estates. He was admitted to the Bar in 2013.”
  • “AI use by attorneys for anything other than legal research should be ‘wholly banned,’ Nevins recommends, adding that even then, the research results should be ‘double checked by each attorney.'”
  • “Attorneys are forwarding AI-generated proposals to their opponents and getting back AI-generated responses or counter proposals, Nevins warns.”
  • “‘We literally have scenarios now where we have AI negotiating contracts with other AI,’ Nevins wrote. ‘This is what we want the legal profession to turn into?'”
  • “Ryan Enage, a civil trial lawyer with Lloyd & McDaniel and a Florida Bar member since 2022, notes that the Florida Supreme Court this summer amended Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.515(d)(2)(Representation by Signer). The amendments state that by filing, the signer of a document represents that ‘the legal authorities identified exist and are accurately cited.'”
  • “The Supreme Court order noted that while AI tools can be helpful, they also can generate content that appears plausible but is in fact inaccurate, including fabricated or ‘hallucinated’ authorities, Enage notes. He also notes that Florida judges in 2000 recommended that pleadings prepared by an attorney and filed on behalf of a pro-se litigant indicate ‘Prepared with the Assistance of Counsel.'”
  • “He recommends that ‘pleadings or other papers in which artificial intelligence was used in their preparation and filed with the court, both prepared by attorneys and prepared by unrepresented parties…indicate ‘Prepared with Assistance of Artificial Intelligence.’'”
  • “Hialeah attorney Arianna Mendez, a Florida Bar member since 2020, says her practice focuses mostly on commercial litigation, business transactions, and real estate disputes.”
  • “‘In my practice, clients have brought me AI-generated legal advice and have shared sensitive information with AI tools,’ Mendez writes. ‘These experiences have raised concerns for me about the discovery implications of clients’ independent use of AI: what records they are creating, what information they are disclosing, and what may need to be preserved.'”
  • “Clients may be mistakenly viewing their use of AI as a ‘private exchange,’ she writes.”
  • “‘I would welcome guidance on how lawyers should counsel clients about these risks, including potential requests for prompts, uploaded materials, and responses.'”
  • “Once a draft is proposed, it will be noticed in the News prior to consideration by the Board of Governors.”
Risk Update

Side Swapping Partner Doesn’t Cause Law Firm Disqualification, RICO Case Against Law Firm Advances, Dealmaking Law Firms Facing Potential Congressional Subpoenas,

Posted on

In the High Court of England and Wales, Family Division:”Law firm can keep acting in dispute after partner swapped sides” —

  • “A law firm representing a woman in a dispute with her ex-husband can continue to act despite hiring the partner who previously supervised the legal work for him, the High Court has ruled.”
  • “‘The existence of a former professional relationship does not itself establish current possession of confidential information,’ said Nageena Khalique KC, sitting as a deputy High Court judge. ‘Nor does the mere possibility that information was once known. Evidence is required… The evidence before me is that Mr Burrows remembers nothing. I accept that evidence.'”
  • “‘C’, represented by Birketts, is in dispute with her ex-husband, ‘A’, over ownership of a property in Tunbridge Wells. A first spoke to Sebastian Burrows, then a partner at Stowe Family Law, in January 2025 and a file was opened the following month.”
  • “Another solicitor handled the day-to-day work but the client-care documentation named Mr Burrows as the partner with overall responsibility. The evidence indicated that A and Mr Burrows were not in direct contact after February.”
  • “Mr Burrows resigned from Stowe in September 2025 and was placed on garden leave until the end of the year, with no access to its systems. In December 2025, Birketts sent a letter before action and A decided to dispense with Stowe and represent himself.”
  • “Mr Burrows joined the Cambridge office Birketts in April, but which time C’s case was already fully pleaded by her legal team, based in Bristol. No new evidence has been disclosed since.”
  • “Nonetheless, A argued before the court that, by virtue of imputed knowledge, Birketts had a conflict of interest and could no longer act.”
  • “Judge Khalique described Mr Burrows as ‘an impressive witness’ and accepted his evidence that he had no recollection of the defendant or the case. He said he had supervised a very substantial caseload at Stowe, involving numerous clients and multiple fee-earners, and had not brought any documents with him either.”
  • “‘Mr Burrows emphasised that he was fully aware of his own professional obligations regarding confidential information and would not jeopardise his own or his employer’s professional reputation by such careless conduct.”
  • “‘He further described that high standards of professional conduct in this regard were practised not only by himself, but by [the fee-earner handling the case] and other members of the team with whom he had worked at Stowe.'”
  • “The judge said the case law did not establish, as A had contended, that imputed knowledge was on its own sufficient to prevent Birketts from acting.”
  • “She said there was ‘simply no evidence’ that Mr Burrows had any confidential information to disclose. He had not contacted C’s team in Bristol and he had no access to the file.”
  • “While there was therefore no need for Birketts or Mr Burrows to provide any undertakings in relation to A’s confidential information, ‘I note that such undertakings have been unconditionally offered on behalf of Birketts and by Mr Burrows. Taken together, they provide substantial additional protection’.”

“Democrats Gain Power to Probe Trump Big Law Deals in Election” —

  • “Democrats’ election win gives them expanded power to investigate deals that major law firms cut with the White House, including some that lawmakers said have stonewalled their inquiries.”
  • “Their majority position greatly increases Democratic lawmakers’ ability to probe the agreements in which nine firms pledged a combined $940 million in free legal services on shared causes with the White House. That topic will compete with a myriad of other oversight targets identified by Democrats, including Trump immigration enforcement, Justice Department misconduct allegations and funding for the White House ballroom project.”
  • “There is a lengthy list of bad actors ‘in this era of oligarchy,’ said Lisa Gilbert, co-president of Public Citizen, a nonprofit consumer advocacy group. ‘It is hard to say at this juncture whether these particular capitulators will rank higher than other places where we’ve seen cronyism occur,’ she said.”
  • “Democrats in both chambers of Congress have vowed to investigate the deals in the new Congress, a posture that could turn up scrutiny on firms Kirkland & Ellis and Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom. A trio of lawmakers, including Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.), have said the firms are stymieing their efforts to gain information about the deals and potential legal services provided.”
  • “‘Notwithstanding Kirkland’s lack of cooperation, we will use every tool at our disposal to pursue this investigation — in this Congress and the next,’ the lawmakers wrote last month in a letter to Jon Ballis, Kirkland’s chairman.”
  • “Democrats have sought a range of information from various law firms that struck deals, including the specific terms of the agreements, detailed descriptions of any pro bono requests from the White House and communications over any proposed agreement or threatened executive order. Lawmakers pressed Kirkland for potential communications it had with Trump’s personal attorney, Boris Epshteyn.”
  • “Big Law firms struck deals with the Trump administration in the months after the president returned to the White House as others were targeted. Trump used executive orders — against Perkins Coie, WilmerHale, Jenner & Block and Susman Godfrey — to direct that lawyers’ security clearances be suspended and access to government buildings be limited. The president also ordered a review of their clients’ government contracts.”
  • “Wall Street’s Paul Weiss was the first firm to strike a deal with Trump, after being hit with an executive order. Eight others signed agreements: Kirkland, Skadden, Latham & Watkins, Milbank, A&O Shearman, Simpson Thacher & Bartlett, Willkie Farr & Gallagher and Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft. Some of those firms faced Equal Employment Opportunity Commission inquiries into their diversity-related employment practices.”
  • “The lawmakers behind the Kirkland letter — Raskin, Blumenthal and Sen. Adam Schiff (Calif.) — say Kirkland failed to produce any responsive documents and refused to meet with congressional staff. Kirkland, the largest US law firm by revenue, pledged $125 million in free legal services in its deal with the Trump administration.”
  • “The same trio of lawmakers in August castigated Skadden’s ‘vague and cursory’ response to their questions about the law firm’s promise to provide $100 million in pro bono legal services. A July letter from lawmakers referenced ‘Skadden’s manifestly corrupt bargain with the President’ and raised concerns about the firm’s work with Intel Corp. on the US government’s stake in the company.”
  • “The possibility of renewed scrutiny from Congress comes as a federal appeals court is set to rule on the Trump administration’s bid to overturn judges’ decisions striking down the orders against the four firms that challenged them in court.”

“PVC giant JM Eagle gets initial OK in RICO suit against law firms” —

  • “A law firm that specializes in filing mesothelioma and asbestos claims must face the civil racketeering lawsuit brought by plastic pipe maker JM Eagle, a Chicago federal judge ruled on Friday.”
  • “The PVC pipe maker has alleged that the two law firms are operating ‘a multi-faceted scheme to defraud that misleads asbestos plaintiffs, state regulators, and asbestos defendants alike.'”
  • “The law firms had argued that JM Eagle’s lawsuit should be dismissed under a legal doctrine known as Noerr-Pennington, which stems from the US Constitution’s First Amendment protection of the right to petition the government. Gettleman held that the doctrine is not an absolute and contains exceptions if the litigation activity is alleged to be a sham.”
  • ‘The court finds that plaintiff has pleaded enough here to avoid dismissal,’ Gettleman said.”
  • “The case, which has been pending in Chicago federal court for two years, now moves into the discovery phase, and the company will be able to examine how the law firms’ claims ‘were generated, investigated and brought,’ said Ashwin Ram, a partner at Buchalter who is representing JM Eagle in the litigation.”
  • “‘This is an important ruling for any company that has faced serial, sham claims under the cover of litigation,’ Ram said.”
  • “JM Eagle, which is pursuing the lawsuit under its prior name J-M Manufacturing, has alleged that Simmons Hanly suppressed evidence, used perjured or falsified testimony and statements, and committed fraud in the course  of recovering billions of dollars from asbestos defendants in thousands of cases.”
  • “Simmons Hanly has filed more than 430 cases against JM Eagle since 2001, according to the lawsuit.”
Risk Update

NRA Sues Former Law Firm for Malpractice, Terminating Representation of Goverment-funded Legal Services, Chancery Court on Advisor Conflicts Disclosure

Posted on

New York State Bar: “Ethics Opinion 1309: Termination of representation by governmentally funded legal services organization” —

  • “If a governmentally funded civil legal services organization loses some or all of its funding, necessitating a reduction in staff, thus increasing the workload of the remaining attorneys, and the remaining attorneys are unable to provide competent representation to existing clients, the organization or its lawyers must seek permission from the tribunal to withdraw as counsel for individual clients, subject to certain conditions.”

“NRA sues Dallas lawyer for nearly destroying the organization he represented” —

  • “The National Rifle Association is demanding that Dallas lawyer William Brewer and his firm, Brewer Attorneys & Counselors, pay back the $200 million in legal fees plus additional damages, alleging the firm committed egregious legal malpractice that caused the gun rights group ‘catastrophic financial and reputational harm.'”
  • “In court documents filed in October, the NRA claims Brewer and his team breached their professional and fiduciary duties in representing the Virginia-based gun advocacy organization over a six-year span in many high-profile legal actions, including against the NRA’s longtime public relations firm and its then-president Lt. Col. Oliver North.”
  • “‘The NRA alleges that, through negligent, conflicted, and self-interested professional representation, the Brewer Firm and Brewer systematically subordinated their client’s interests to their own – and, in doing so, inflicted catastrophic financial and reputational harm on the organization they were retained to protect,’ the NRA claims in court documents.”
  • “The NRA states that it retained the Brewer firm in March 2018 in a sole ‘narrow engagement to shepherd the NRA through a single insurance-regulatory inquiry.'”
  • “Brewer’s work for the NRA ‘quickly metastasized over more than six years into a sprawling, nationwide representation that came within a breath of destroying the organization it was retained to defend,’ court documents state.”
  • “The NRA claims that Brewer ‘pursued a legal strategy that repeatedly exacerbated the NRA’s exposure instead of mitigating it.'”
  • “The filing Friday states that Brewer and his firm had ‘actual knowledge of the very executive misconduct that placed the NRA in regulatory peril’ but instead ‘chose to conceal and disregard misconduct rather than cure it’ and thus ‘shielding’ the NRA’s former leader Wayne LaPierre ‘in order to further protect the firm’s and Brewer’s own interests.'”
  • “The NRA, in the documents, cites five specific matters in which it argues that the Brewer Firm committed legal malpractice, breach of fiduciary duty, knowing participation in a breach of fiduciary duty and negligent misrepresentation.”
  • “The NRA’s filing also claims that the Brewer Firm ‘engineered a secret Chapter 11 bankruptcy that the federal bankruptcy court dismissed as not filed in good faith and condemned as shocking.’ ‘The failed bankruptcy filing cost the NRA tens of millions of dollars in out-of-pocket attorneys’ fees and expenses, including over $5 million paid to the Brewer Firm, and millions of dollars in reputational and economic damages,’ court documents state.”
  • “The lawyers in this new litigation are extremely familiar with each other, and they were on opposite sides of some of these same disputes for the past several years.”
  • “The NRA hired Greenberg Traurig partners Michael Gruber and Brian Mason. Gruber and Mason represented Ackerman McQueen in the litigation against the NRA when they were lawyers at Dorsey & Whitney.”

“Fully informed, not infinitely informed: Chancery Court clarifies advisor-conflict disclosure under Corwin – Quorum: Boardroom insights into governance, M&A, and securities law” —

  • “The Delaware Court of Chancery, in Berger v. Fox, dismissed a putative class action challenging an all-cash take-private merger of a publicly traded wealth management company with affiliates of a private equity firm.”
  • “The Court held that the business judgment rule disposed of plaintiffs’ fiduciary duty claims because the merger was approved by a fully informed, uncoerced vote of the disinterested stockholders, applying the Delaware Supreme Court’s landmark decision Corwin v. KKR Financial Holdings LLC.”
  • “The Court rejected Plaintiffs’ contention that the vote was not fully informed due to inadequate disclosure of alleged financial advisor and law firm conflicts, noting that all material information concerning these relationships and fees was adequately disclosed in the company’s proxy statement. The decision reaffirms the enduring power of Corwin cleansing in Delaware and provides useful disclosure guidance where board advisors have prior or pending relationships with transactional counterparties.”
  • “Plaintiffs filed suit, alleging that the Envestnet board conducted a flawed merger process and withheld material information about the Financial Advisor’s and Law Firm’s conflicts in connection with the stockholder vote. Plaintiffs asserted claims for breach of fiduciary duty against Envestnet’s directors and CEO, and for aiding and abetting against the Financial Advisor.”
  • “The Court found no indicia of bad faith in Plaintiffs’ allegations. The Court noted that the independent board ‘inform[ed] itself of potential conflicts, engag[ed] with multiple bidders, and met[] over a dozen times before reaching a deal.'”
  • “Delaware courts will closely scrutinize potential advisor conflicts and require full disclosure of investment banker compensation and potential conflicts in the proxy statement provided to stockholders. Berger, however, clarifies that when a financial advisor faces a conflict, it is generally sufficient for the board to disclose ‘the relationship itself and the amount of fees the advisor received.’ The board is not required to disclose ‘the specific fees a financial advisor received from unrelated work for a transactional counterparty,’ so long as the relationship and a ‘rough scale’ of those fees are disclosed.”
  • “Berger highlights that boards may properly rely on advisors in strategic processes—even those with relationships with counterparties—without losing all-important Corwin business judgment protection. The key is (i) identifying potential conflicts as soon as possible and (ii) adequately disclosing all material information concerning to stockholders in advance of a Corwin-cleansing vote. In Berger, the Court concluded that the board did both, resulting in dismissal of all claims.”
jobs

BRB Risk Jobs Board — Conflicts Attorney (Dentons)

Posted on

In this BRB jobs update, I’m pleased to spotlight two open positions at Dentons: “Conflicts Attorney” —

  • Dentons US LLP is currently recruiting for a Conflicts Attorney.
  • This position will provide support to all levels of personnel throughout the Firm and US Region and will be responsible for review and analysis of conflicts and other issues related to firm acceptance of new clients and new matters.
  • The position is open to any Dentons office, is a remote position and required to work Pacific Standard business hours.


Responsibilities

  • Review and provide thorough and timely analysis of all firm new business to identify legal and business conflicts of interest.
  • Utilize available internal and external databases to review and analyze conflicts of interest reports with respect to clients, matters and prospective business.
  • Facilitate resolution of potential conflicts issues for lawyer’s firm wide.
  • Advise as to necessary waivers. Assist in drafting waivers and engagement letters or other documentation for
  • Partner review and/or submission to clients.
  • Proactively communicate with department leadership on complex conflicts questions and other compliance issues.
  • Maintain thorough, accurate and current records of all conflicts resolutions to ensure integrity of the database and assist in identification and clearing of future conflicts of interest.
  • Investigate and resolve erroneous, outdated or otherwise incomplete data on conflicts reports to maintain integrity of information in firm conflicts databases and other records.
  • These duties may be ongoing or ad hoc in nature.
  • Other duties may be assigned to fully meet the requirements of the position.


Experience & Qualifications

  • Juris Doctor (J.D.) required
  • Must be licensed to practice law with at least 2 years’ conflicts experience in a law firm.
  • Strong oral and written communication skills required.
  • Ability to collaborate productively with firm personnel at all levels.
  • Strong analytical, interpersonal, and organizational skills required.
  • Methodical approach to work with a strong focus on accuracy, attention to details, consistency, and quality.
  • Able to effectively negotiate with and influence colleagues and others to achieve a successful outcome.
  • Strong legal research skills. In addition, stay current with recent research and thinking on ethics and conflicts best practices and rules across jurisdictions in which the firm has offices. Maintain a sophisticated, relevant base of knowledge in these areas.
  • Able to work under pressure to tight project deadlines and can adapt to differing demands, prioritizing tasks where appropriate and ensuring complete ‘follow through’ on outstanding issues.
  • Demonstrated ability to make recommendations to effectively resolve problems or issues by using judgment that is consistent with standards, practices, policies, procedures, regulation, or government law.
  • Knowledge of Intapp conflict checking, ethical wall and business intake software a plus.

See the complete job posting for more detail and to apply for this position.

And if you’re interested in seeing your firm’s listings here, please feel free to reach out…

Risk Update

Former Client Conflict, Side-Switching Lawyer, Initial Interview, Bankruptcy Conflict, and More

Posted on

Always with our thanks for his diligent efforts, here’s the latest of note from Bill Freivogel:

  • Engel v. Ulvestad, 2026 WL 3205372 (Minn. App. Oct. 26, 2026).
    • This is a boundary-line dispute involving the use of a private surveyor as an expert witness. One party moved to disqualify the surveyor. The trial court denied the motion, and, in this opinion, the appellate court affirmed.
    • The surveyor’s company had been bought by a parent company. The parent company had earlier rendered an arguably contrary opinion. The appellate court upheld the trial court on two bases: (1) The moving party had not objected when the surveyor testified with no objection in an earlier trial of this matter; and, (2) The moving party was not making a breach-of-confidentiality claim.
  • Citizens of Humanity, LLC v. RLI Ins. Co., 2026 WL 3258510 (9th Cir. Oct. 29, 2026).
    • In this one-page opinion the appellate court, interpreting California cases, ruled that because InsCo had issued a “general” (not specific) reservation of rights, the insured could not claim a conflict of interest and right to independent counsel.
  • Cymbidium Restoration Trust v. Am. Homeowner Preservation Trust, No. C24-0025-KKE (W.D. Wash. Oct. 26, 2026).
    • Plaintiff, Cymbidium moved to disqualify Law Firm from representing Defendant, AHP, under Rule 1.9(a) (former client rule). In this opinion the court granted the motion.
    • Law Firm never represented Plaintiff, but it earlier represented non-party Oak Harbor in preparing a mortgage sale agreement, which was an earlier version of the agreement involved in this case.
    • Oak Harbor manages Plaintiff’s real estate investments. Because of that relationship, and because Oak Harbor is a party in separate but related litigation, Law Firm is being adverse to Oak Harbor in this case. Thus, Plaintiff has standing to make the motion.
    • Moreover, given that many of the provisions prepared by Law Firm in the earlier version of the agreement remain in the current version, this case is substantially related to the earlier representation.
  • Doe v. Lewis Roca Rothgerber Christie LLP, 2026 WL 3181223 (D.N.M. Oct. 22, 2026).
    • In this legal malpractice case the court, in this opinion, denied Law Firm’s motion for summary judgement. Plaintiff had brought proceedings in Rhode Island against her Catholic school and a school employee for child sexual abuse. The claim against the school was barred by the statute of limitations.
    • Law Firm had represented Plaintiff in a suit for injunction against the employee, not the school. Plaintiff’s main claim against Law Firm was the firm did not advise Plaintiff she might have a claim against the school itself within the time allowed by the statute of limitations.
    • Complicating Law Firm’s situation, the school was paying Law Firm’s fees in the injunction case, and Law Firm, over the years, had received millions in fees from Catholic institutions, including for defending sexual abuse cases.
    • Given the material limitation provisions of New Mexico’s versions of MR 1.7(a)(2) and the fee provisions of MR 1.8(f), a jury could find Law Firm’s conduct fell below the standard of care in not timely advising Plaintiff about suing the school.
  • Morrison v. MSI Spergel Inc., 2026 ONCA 738 (Ct. App. Ont. Oct. 20, 2026).
    • Bankruptcy Trustee sought a declaration that Bankrupt “made a transfer at undervalue” to his wife. The motion judge found the transfer was partially void. A creditor appealed the order in part because the Trustee’s lawyer (“Lawyer”) had a conflict of interest.
    • Lawyer had earlier represented Bankrupt on matters relating to his financial situation. In this proceeding, among other things, Lawyer on behalf of the Trustee accused Bankrupt of intent to “defraud, defeat or delay a creditor” and moved to compel Bankrupt to make certain financial disclosures. In this decision, based upon Lawyer’s conflict, the appellate court set aside the motion judge’s order, directed a new hearing in Superior Court, and disqualified Lawyer from representing the Trustee. (Elbows up, Canada!)
  • De Cotiis v. De Cotiis, 2026 BCSC 2001 (CanLII) (S. Ct. B.C. Oct. 13, 2026).
    • Plaintiff moved to disqualify the law firm (“Law Firm”) for Defendant Hughes because Plaintiff had had contacts with a lawyer in Law Firm (“Lawyer A”) about possibly representing Plaintiff in this matter. In this opinion the court denied the motion to disqualify, because: (1) Plaintiff had not formally retained Law Firm; (2) a different lawyer in Law Firm (“Lawyer B”) was representing Hughes: and (3) Law Firm had erected a screen between Lawyers A and B.
    • After an extensive discussion of all the circumstances of the contacts between Plaintiff and Law Firm, including an analysis of information conveyed by Plaintiff to Law Firm, the court concluded that the chance of prejudice to Plaintiff was minimal to non-existent. The opinion contains a good discussion of the interplay among the Supreme Court’s MacDonald Estate decision, the B.C. Rules, and several B.C. decisions and their application here.
jobs

BRB Risk Jobs Board — Director & Counsel, New Business Intake (Davis Graham & Stubbs)

Posted on

In this BRB jobs update, I’m pleased to highlight an open role at Davis, Graham  & Stubbs: “Director & Counsel, New Business Intake” —

  • The Director and Counsel, New Business Intake leads the firm’s Conflicts and New Business Intake department and identifies and manages the ethical and business risks presented by potential new business opportunities for the firm.
  • The person in this role is responsible for conflicts clearance review and analysis for firm-wide legal hires and new business, and for the overall strategy, operation, staffing, and continuous improvement of the conflicts and new business intake function.
  • The Director and Counsel works directly with the Chief Financial Officer and the firm’s General Counsel and Ethics Attorney, as well as with attorneys, Business Acceptance Partners, and the firm’s Risk Management Committee, to identify and resolve potential ethics and business conflict issues.
  • This position directly supervises the firm’s Conflicts Analyst and New Business Intake Specialist.
  • This position requires strong knowledge of the rules of professional responsibility, firm policies, and sound analysis of potential conflict issues.
  • The attorneys and firm management rely upon the Director and Counsel’s information and judgment in making decisions about whether or not to accept new legal hires, clients, and matters.


Essential Functions:

  • Review and analyze conflict report results, communicating directly with appropriate attorneys and others to obtain clarification and additional detail in order to resolve identified conflict issues and properly document the resolution.
  • Research existing engagement documentation, firm financial data, and corporate affiliations as necessary to clear conflicts independently.
  • Provide attorneys with concise and complete evaluations of potential conflict or relationship issues and identify possible approaches for resolution.
  • Draft and provide conflicts waiver requests in consultation with involved attorneys and the firm’s General Counsel, Ethics Counsel, and/or Chief Financial Officer as appropriate.
  • Review and analyze terms of engagement, client-generated engagement documents, and outside counsel guidelines both as part of the new business intake process and subsequent to client engagement.
  • Review new matter submissions for compliance with firm policies and ethical standards and completion of all necessary engagement and waiver correspondence.
  • Serve as the escalation point for exceptions to the firm’s new matter intake policies, including deviations from the firm’s standard terms of engagement, prior to approval by a Business Acceptance Partner.
  • Review and act on high-risk or negative findings from prospective client investigations and other background research circulated by department staff, providing instructions on further diligence or escalation.
  • Review and analyze lateral attorney prior work history conflicts reports, working with the firm’s General Counsel, Ethics Counsel, Chief Talent Officer, and/or Chief Financial Officer to resolve any conflicts.
  • Supervise implementation of ethical walls when required.
  • Oversee the process of closing out clients and matters, including closing correspondence.
  • Develop, document, and implement conflicts and new business intake policies, procedures, and technologies, and oversee audits of the conflicts and client matter databases to maintain data integrity.
  • Maintain the firm’s engagement, dis-engagement, and waiver letter templates, modifying them from time to time to reflect new ethics and risk management initiatives.
  • Oversee process improvements to the firm’s Intapp conflict system, including system upgrades, form modifications, and workflow adjustments as needed.
  • Supervise, train, and mentor the firm’s Conflicts Analyst and New Business Intake Specialist, including assigning and prioritizing work, reviewing work product, and acting as a back-up to those positions from time to time.
  • Direct the strategy and day-to-day operations of the Conflicts and New Business Intake department, establishing priorities, performance metrics, and service standards to ensure timely and accurate conflicts clearance and matter opening.
  • Maintain knowledge of developments in professional responsibility law and regulations, as well as trends and new technologies impacting the new business intake function.
  • Serve as a key risk management resource for the firm’s Risk Management Committee.
  • Assist with training around new business intake best practices and business acceptance processes.
  • Additional duties as assigned by the firm’s Chief Financial Officer.
  • Perform other duties as assigned

 

Required Skills/Abilities

  • Superior attention to detail, focused critical thinking, sound judgment and strong decision-making skills to be able to identify the potential issues with bringing on new business and new employees to the firm.
  • Strong oral and written communication skills, including the ability to understand, analyze, interpret, and explain complex reports and to converse informatively with attorneys and staff about conflicts issues.
  • Excellent organization skills, including the ability to work collaboratively and provide an accurate work product with minimal supervision in an atmosphere of multiple projects, shifting priorities, and extremely tight deadline pressures.
  • Possess a high level of ethical and professional responsibility and superior judgment in handling confidential information.
  • Strong ability to learn new technologies, processes, and workflows as necessary.
  • Willingness to keep updated on trends and developments in the industry and to continue to develop skills, knowledge, and ability to improve processes and procedures.
  • Demonstrated leadership and people-management skills, including the ability to hire, train, motivate, and evaluate staff and to foster a collaborative team environment.


Required Education and Experience

  • JD degree and active bar license in Colorado or your state of residence.
  • Minimum of five years of experience working in a law firm, law department, or other professional services business.
  • Strong knowledge of ethical, legal, and risk management concepts and rules relating to conflicts of interest and new business intake.
  • Resourceful internet research skills utilizing various online sources and business databases such as Dun & Bradstreet, Hoovers, Securities & Exchange Commission, Lexis/Nexis, Capital IQ, etc.


Preferred Education and Experience

  • 3+ years of experience with law firm conflicts and/or new business department preferred.
  • Experience utilizing and overseeing a conflicts database and related conflicts checking software, preferably Intapp Open.
  • Prior experience supervising or managing staff in a law firm conflicts, new business intake, or risk management department.

 

See the complete job posting for more details on the job requirements and to apply for this position.

Learn more about working at the firm on their careers page:

  • Davis Graham business professionals are the foundation of our service-based organization
  • Excellence in service comes from every member of our team, every day. We are committed to attracting and retaining employees who share our values: integrity, respect, fairness, diversity in background and interests, a good sense of humor, and collegiality.


And if you’re interested in seeing your firm’s listings here, please feel free to
reach out…

Risk Update

Navigating Unnamed Class Member Conflicts of Interest, Law Firm Partner Business Relationship Risk and Lateral Practices

Posted on

Dear Ethics Lawyer writes: “Conflict with Unnamed Class Members” —

  • “Q: Dear Ethics Lawyer, I am defending a putative class action for one of our firm’s largest business clients. Plaintiff’s counsel frequently files class actions and has at least four of them, that I am aware of, against clients of our firm. The class described in the suit I am defending is quite broad, which gave me an idea. After looking into it, I believe that at least two of our clients who are currently being sued by plaintiff’s firms in other matters would be within the class described in the matter I am defending. It seems to me that this places plaintiff’s counsel adverse to their own class members. Doesn’t this create a conflict under Rule 1.7 for which I could seek their disqualification?”
  • “A: As I often write in this column, you should check authorities in your applicable jurisdiction, but Model Rule 1.7 appears to address this situation in defining who the lawyer’s client is in the context of class actions. Comment 25 to Rule 1.7 provides:”
    • “When a lawyer represents or seeks to represent a class of plaintiffs or defendants in a class-action lawsuit, unnamed members of the class are ordinarily not considered to be clients of the lawyer for purposes of applying paragraph (a)(1) of this Rule. Thus, the lawyer does not typically need to get the consent of such a person before representing a client suing the person in an unrelated matter. Similarly, a lawyer seeking to represent an opponent in a class action does not typically need the consent of an unnamed member of the class whom the lawyer represents in an unrelated matter.”
  • “In your situation, the fact that plaintiff’s counsel in your case is adverse to unnamed class members in other matters does not (at least without more) create a conflict for them.”
  • “The situation would be different if a named class representative was adverse to their counsel. It could also be different if there were facts creating a material limitation conflict under Rule 1.7(a)(2) concerning plaintiff’s counsel’s representation of the class while being adverse to one of the unnamed class members in other matter(s), e.g., possibly arising from any centrality of the unnamed class member in proof or defense of the allegations in the suit.”
  • “Similarly, although perhaps unlikely, you should also consider whether your defense of the class action creates any issues (material limitation conflict or otherwise) with your representation of other firm clients whom you know to be members of the class.”

“Weil Gotshal’s Closest Relationship Cost the Firm Everything” —

  • “At Weil Gotshal & Manges, there was no relationship more important than that between Mike Aiello, its highest paid partner and most prodigious business generator, and Barry Wolf, its longtime executive partner. Their story is the story of Weil’s final decade. Their relationship dictated the firm’s strategy and decisions. It decided who stayed at the firm and who left. And when it shattered, the firm did too.”
  • “Interviews with more than a dozen people, most of whom held leadership positions at Weil, point out how the complex relationship between Wolf and Aiello—and key misunderstandings between the pair—set the stage for the firm’s implosion within weeks of Aiello’s announced departure to Cravath. The sources were allowed to speak without being identified in order to describe a dynamic that many of them are still grappling to process. Some described being asked in recent days whether Weil’s fall shocked them.”
  • “Weil had been falling behind its competitors gradually but consistently over the almost two decades that Wolf and Aiello practiced together. Its revenue growth was half the annualized rate of its competitors from 2008 to 2025, according to data from The American Lawyer and Citi’s law firm banking group.”
  • “But Aiello’s status as the firm’s largest business generator meant firm leaders were unwilling to part ways with him—even as he became a source of contention at board meetings over his unwillingness to invest in new practice areas. That meant the task of dealing with Aiello fell to Wolf—the man Aiello pledged his loyalty to for so long.”
  • “The pair were bound in many ways, including a provision Wolf negotiated when he became the firm’s leader that he would always be paid the same as the firm’s highest paid partner. In recent years, that was Aiello. That dynamic complicated people’s view of their relationship and their respective jobs—Wolf’s only role was to run the firm; Aiello was tasked with client matters.”
  • “As Wolf became preoccupied with managing Aiello, the law firm that was proud to be glued together by a family dynamic stumbled and tripped headfirst into a commercial-minded business model adopted by rivals who devoured it. It is nearly impossible to answer the inevitable question: Did Wolf fail at his job, or did Aiello neutralize effectively the only boss he ever had?”
  • “‘I’d hate to admit that parts of that are true, but we were largely partners and people felt a certain allegiance to a certain degree,’ one former partner said. ‘And that came a little bit from Barry and Mike.'”
  • “Partner loyalty to Weil carried a cost and the firm didn’t pay as well as some of its closest rivals. Its partners earned more than $5 million on average last year, lower than the $8 million to $10 million at competitors. Still, many partners were happy with the trade for quite some time, even as the industry grew to be defined by lateral jumping between firms.”
  • “Aiello and Wolf were somewhat ill-suited for those recruiting wars, viewing the business through their lens of loyalty. Why would you hire a partner who was proving their disloyalty by leaving their firm? “
  • “Instead, they focused on bringing back lawyers who had left Weil once before. They were proving how special Weil was by returning. Wolf called Aiello ‘the original boomerang.’ He had returned to Weil at Wolf’s urging amid Dewey’s merger talks with Orrick in 2008, a move that the American Lawyer reported contemporaneously was a key factor in those discussions’ failure.”
  • “Aiello disliked lateral partner hiring so much that when a rival firm recruited a handful of its lawyers, a powerful partner at that firm was told Aiello was trying to get his phone number. The partner believed Aiello was going to dress him down, even if the call never came in the end. Standard business practice when losing a partner in Big Law is to shrug and say, ‘Best of luck in your future endeavors.'”
  • “‘There is a humane side to both of them,’ said one former partner. ‘But the lesson to me is humans are not perfect. We’re all imperfect. We all have our faults. And we have to forgive each other.'”
  • “The run on the bank at Weil was perverse in the sense that it was started by some of the firm’s highest paid partners and its harshest impacts will be felt by its most vulnerable employees. And that’s true. But the wealthiest members of the firm, by virtue of their own success that the firm relied upon, had the closest proximity to the Wolf-Aiello alliance, to where they may have understood it in ways that differed even from the two men themselves. Many of them seemed to sense it would be the firm’s demise. Some had predicted it for years.”
    “As of September, the two seemed to still have a misunderstanding whether Aiello had agreed to stay on past Wolf’s retirement. Sources familiar with the matter say the two spoke on Sept. 8. Wolf was asking Aiello to commit to staying as the firm recovered from recent departures. It is unclear the two men came to an understanding.”
    “What is known is that on Sept. 10, Aiello’s team walked into Wolf’s office and submitted their resignations, including on Aiello’s behalf. Their breakup wasn’t face-to-face. It was over text.”
  • “Aiello chose Cravath, one reason being that it was willing to take his entire team, a display of the personal loyalty some saw as the best in him. Still, others viewed his decision as an ultimate betrayal.”
  • “The timing couldn’t have been worse. Coupled with the major departures from the firm’s private equity practice, Weil’s PE service capabilities by the time Aiello quit were severely diminished. Neither of the top lawyers at two of the firm’s most important clients have responded to questions about whether they would have kept working with Weil, though there are rumors they would not.”
Risk Update

On Emerging Agentic AI Risk for Law Firms, On Potential OCGs and Engagement Evolution in the Age of AI, On Time Entry AI and Client Economic Risk

Posted on

Joseph Tiano opines: “Law Firms Must Re-Engineer AI Use to Prevent Unauthorized Actions” —

  • “As I read the news this weekend, I’m coming around to the view that the next-generation AI problem for law firms won’t be a hallucinated answer or an unverified court filing. It will be a capable tool that took an action nobody approved. Firms need to start thinking about this now.”
  • “Two incidents from this week’s news show how general AI risks in other scenarios may translate over to the law firm context.”
  • “Incident one. During testing, Claude was running example tasks on randomly selected webpages. It landed on PhillyUnsolvedMurders.com and filled out a form suggesting it had information about an unsolved murder. Police say the submission was marked as spam and never reached investigators. Apparently Anthropic reported the incident”
  • “Incident two. In a report Friday, Anthropic disclosed that another model submitted forms to an undisclosed government website when it was supposed to stop before submitting. Anthropic calls this agent persistence.”
  • “The failures differ, but they share a gap: no human approved the specific action. In the first, nothing limited where the agent could act. In the second, a stop-point existed and the agent went past it.”
  • “AI didn’t create this gap. It exposed it. Today, if the duties of competence, diligence and supervision are followed, a lawyer is usually the last step before anything is filed or sent, so most firms never had to define anything beyond the final human approver control. Agents remove that step by default.”
  • “Law firms have three options:”
    • “1. Resist. Ban agents, and watch shadow use appear anyway.”
    • “2. Patch. Issue a policy memo. (just like outside counsel guidelines, such a memo is a hopeful control at best.)”
    • “3. Re-engineer. Scope what each tool can reach, require human approval at the final step, and log every action.”
  • Only the third option really holds up. Bans get routed around, and memos can’t be enforced particularly well.”
  • “To re-engineer, I think it starts with an analysis of existing data pools: billing data, LPM data and DMs data where you can break each service into workflows by task and phase. Then map where an agent can act on its own and where it must stop for approval.”

Tiano also offers some compliance and risk management advice in another post: “California Regulates Lawyers Use of AI: Self Regulation, Delegation, and Liability Concerns” —

  • “California just regulated how lawyers use AI. It’s well intended, but it raises a question I can’t stop asking as a legal ethics guy: what happened to lawyers regulating themselves? Was ABA Formal Opinion 512, our own guidance on generative AI, structurally inadequate?”
  • “SB 574 takes effect January 1, 2027. Hundreds of decisions have sanctioned lawyers for hallucinated citations, so I understand the impulse. But SB 574 asks lawyers to meet standards the statute never defines, and the profession was not asked to define them. “
  • “Lawyers may use AI ‘to assist in the practice of law’ but may not ‘delegate’ it. I kinda get the difference but the line is undefined, and so is the term it depends on. ‘Practice of law’ has never had a clean definition. Unauthorized practice of law (UPL) rules vary by state, courts often decide case by case, and the definition has long been murky at the edges: document preparation, legal information versus legal advice, and now software that drafts and analyzes. If ‘practice of law’ means everything lawyers do, no AI drafting is allowed. If it means legal judgment, the statute should say so.”
  • “None of the four duties in the statute has a stated remedy, and the statute creates no cause of action. The only express remedy, sanctions under § 128.7, covers the citation rule alone, runs to opposing parties, and deters rather than compensates. So if a lawyer violates the statute, what can a client assert? Malpractice? Breach of fiduciary duty? Is a violation negligence per se, evidence of the standard of care, or nothing? And what are the damages? A fake citation may impact a court more than the client. A confidentiality breach raises harder questions: what is the loss, and was privilege waived? The statute is also silent on the witnesses and victims whose addresses and phone numbers it protects. And this is just a knee jerk reaction I had. “
  • “What I’d do: measure and monitor: Log which tool touched which task, who verified what, and who made the legal judgment call, then monitor those records over time. When duties come without defined liability, enforcement defaults to State Bar discipline, malpractice carriers, and clients.”
    “Right away, I’d pull billing records from ten recent matters and ask whether you could show, from your own records, where a lawyer exercised judgment and where AI assisted. If you can’t, that gap is your compliance risk.”

And for those intrigued by these future-forward and emerging issues, see this fascinating thought exercise: “Law Department 2.0: When Clients Take Control (Part II)” —

  • “What happens when clients really have command of their data?”
  • “Law firms are governed by Outside Counsel Guidelines (OCGs). In addition to billing guidance, OCGs increasingly focus on how work gets done and when automation is expected. What if clients directed more of the systems that law firms use?”
  • “What if firms were required to perform certain work within a client-controlled research environment, perhaps by leveraging a client instance of a legal research service? The client could gain additional insights into how the work was done, including search strategies and the AI prompts used to approach the matter. That information could help with risk assessment and decision-making. It would also become part of the client’s institutional knowledge so future matters have greater context.”
  • “The same could hold true for workflows defined by the client using its preferred AI platform, or legal operating system, as some vendors call their platforms. Think Claude for Enterprise, Harvey, Eudia, or other solutions.”
  • “In the future, panel participants might be required to use a ‘legal operating system’ to complete work. “
  • “In AI, a harness is the surrounding infrastructure that constrains and directs a model’s operation. Perhaps OCGs evolve into something resembling Outside Counsel Harnesses (OCHs), defining not just billing rules but the technology and processes that firms must use to perform the work.”
  • “Matter information already travels with a lateral between firms to put the client first. Wouldn’t it make more sense for the matter information to just stay with the client in the first place?”
  • “This may be jolting for law firms, and to be fair, there would be much to think through. There will be situations where a firm has proprietary know-how and shouldn’t expect to give it up. Complicated situations, such as multiparty litigation, would pose challenges too. To be clear, I’m not suggesting that all work becomes controlled by the client, but the seesaw may tilt more in that direction. “
  • “The very expertise that clients rely upon may atrophy if firms can’t benefit from the knowledge gained on a matter, too. That’s not good for anyone. It’s also in clients’ interest for firms to retain their ability to specialize. “
  • “In the future, clients will require firms to conform even more closely to their preferences regarding how work is completed.”

And when AI meets Time Entry: “Finally, A Way To Measure AI ROI: Be Careful What You Ask For” —

  • “In case anyone wasn’t listening, Legora, the legal AI provider, and Laurel, a work intelligence platform provider, recently announced a ‘partnership.’ A partnership that reportedly has two main parts. It will offer what sounds like a fairly standard timekeeping tool. But it holds out the promise of an intriguing future tool that raises some possibilities.”
  • “What Legora and Laurel are promising is to give law firm management the ability to determine the ROI on their purchase of Legora. The ROI for most AI platforms has indeed proven elusive, except for administrative and nonbillable work where AI replaces human work. I can only assume those trying to determine Legora’s ROI have faced the same difficulty. Hence the effort.”
  • “The whole premise is that the AI will do work, perhaps much of which had previously been done by paralegals or associates. That’s billable work, and for firms that use the billable hour model, that’s hardly a return on investment. To the contrary, it’s a loss. Try explaining at the next partners’ meeting that you’ve just spent a ton of money on something that reduces their year-end shares. And be ready for the question: is it too late to back out of this deal? Time saved is not necessarily money earned.”
  • “The Legora/Laurel partnership presumably will measure the time saved by Legora AI. Which is easily convertible to dollars. The question then becomes: What does a law firm do with those dollars? Does it pass them on to the client? And what if clients want to see those numbers?”
  • “As in, ‘We want to see the savings your tools came up with so we can determine whether our bills reflect that reduction.’ What happens when the tool for justifying the technology investment becomes negotiating leverage for the client? Once you start measuring AI’s value, the next question is who gets to keep it.”
jobs

BRB Risk Jobs Board — Conflicts Analyst – PST (DLA Piper)

Posted on

I’m pleased to highlight a new open role at DLA Piper: “Conflicts Analyst — PST” —

  • As a Conflicts Analyst, working in collaboration with and in support of the firm’s strategic initiatives, you will support the firm’s critical risk management function by performing all duties associated with conflict of interest resolution, including: analyzing and resolving potential legal and business conflicts identified in connection with new client and matter intake forms submitted via the New Business Intake System; drafting email waivers and conflict waiver letters; implementing information barriers and ensuring proper notification to affected personnel; and collaborating with partners and Professional Responsibility Counsel in an effort to assist in bringing in new business to the firm.

 

Responsibilities:

  • Reviews, interprets, and summarizes conflict report results.
  • Analyzes and resolves potential legal and business conflicts.
  • Implements information barriers and ensures proper notification to affected personnel.
  • Drafts formal email waivers and conflict waiver letters to ensure proper documentation of legal or business conflicts relating to new business.
  • Maintains conflict information in the financial database, including related party information and client/matter narratives relating to conflicts resolution notes.
  • Reviews new business intake forms and identifies conflicts in order to ensure accuracy, including verifying information, conducting corporate research, and communicating with all levels of personnel of the firm in order to ensure accurate conflict clearance.
  • Maintains internal conflicts database and ensures proper and accurate documentation of legal and business conflicts.
  • Performs corporate research on all parties involved in new business requests in order to confirm relationships to existing firm clients.
  • Other duties as assigned.

 

Desired Skills:

  • Must have experience writing and communicating in a business environment in order to present information in a concise and meaningful end product.
  • Experience with intake and conflicts software preferred.
  • Excellent verbal and written business communication skills, with demonstrated ability to exercise good judgment and make sound decisions, while maintaining a customer service-oriented manner.
  • The ability to apply critical thinking in evaluating different conflicts scenarios or outcomes and be adaptable to changes in the procedures or direction.
  • Meticulous attention to detail and a proven ability to prioritize and multitask, with the ability to work under pressure and meet deadlines in a fast-paced environment while maintaining high level work product.
  • Ability to identify data integrity issues and subsequently resolve them appropriately.

Minimum Education: High School Diploma or GED.

Minimum Education: Bachelor’s Degree.

Certificates: Paralegal certificate preferred.

Minimum Years of Experience: 2 years of direct experience in conflicts or new business intake department within a law firm, paralegal or similar experience required.

 

Essential Job Expectations

All DLA Piper employees are expected to demonstrate excellence in how we serve our clients and develop our people, upholding our firm values as part of our culture. Specific expectations include:

  • Communicate effectively, both verbally and in writing, with clients, lawyers, business professionals, and external audiences.
  • Produce high-quality work and respond to correspondence in an efficient, timely, and professional manner.
  • Meet deadlines, manage competing priorities, and commit to meeting high standards.
  • Comply with firm policies and procedures.
  • Maintain confidences as required in a law firm environment.

 

About DLA Piper

DLA Piper is, at its core, bold, exceptional, collaborative and supportive. Our people are the backbone, heart and soul of our firm. Wherever you are in your professional journey, DLA Piper is a place you can engage in meaningful work and grow your career. Let’s see what we can achieve. Together.

 

See the complete job posting for more details on the job and to apply for this position. And learn more about the firm on their careers page.

 

And if you’re interested in seeing your firm’s listings here, please feel free to reach out…

Risk Update

Intra-firm Information Security Causes Client Consternation, Yale Law Journal on MSO Governance Gaps, TN Rejects Private Equity Law Firm Involvement, Cloned Called Out,

Posted on

David Kluft asks: “Can my client instruct me not to share information within my firm?” —

  • “A WY civil litigant with counsel decided to file a pro se motion for sanctions against her own lawyers. The litigant claimed she shared information with an associate at the firm, and that the associate breached confidentiality by sharing the information with others at the firm.”
  • “The court cited to Comment 5 to the WY Rule 1.6: ‘Lawyers in a firm may, in the course of the firm’s practice, disclose to each other information relating to a client of the firm, unless the client has instructed that particular information be confined to specified lawyers’ (ABA and many states have the same comment).”
  • “Because there was no evidence the client had instructed the associate not to share the information (and for other reasons), the motion was denied.”
  • Decision: here.

Yale Law Journal on: “Private Equity’s Law Firm Workaround: MSOs, Rule 5.4, and the Governance Gap” —

  • “Private equity is moving aggressively into the legal sector, and the profession’s oversight infrastructure is wholly unprepared for this generational shift. To work around prohibitions against nonlawyer ownership, investors are repurposing the management-services organization (MSO): a split-entity model in which attorneys retain the regulated practice, but investors acquire the firm’s operating platform.”
  • “This Essay provides the first systematic account of private-equity investment in law firms and the governance gap in which it is occurring—a vacuum unrecognized by the American Bar Association, state bars, or courts. The playbook is seasoned; the risks are not hypothetical. After pioneering the model with healthcare, private equity fundamentally reshaped accounting through hundreds of transactions in just a few years, with regulators scrambling only after the fact. Law is next.”
  • “The MSO model rests on the fragile assumption that ‘business operations’ and ‘legal practice’ can be clearly and durably separated. Healthcare and accounting experience proves otherwise, with similar split structures consistently exhibiting formality erosion and investor ‘control creep’ through financial and operational pressure. Governance tensions run deep: the structurally conflicted MSO board must build value while policing its own influence over the interlinked law firm.”
  • “The problem is not the MSO model per se, but the transactions proliferating in darkness without guardrails. This Essay proposes a three-part governance framework: (1) structural safeguards limiting MSOs to genuine support functions; (2) independent directors and a board ethics committee; and (3) ongoing compliance monitoring. The ultimate costs of the governance gap will fall on the public, not on investors. The window to act is closing fast.”

“Tennessee Supreme Court Rejects PE Law Firm Ownership” —

  • “After considering potential updates to its rules on attorney licensing, the Supreme Court of Tennessee has announced that it will not be changing its regulations barring nonlawyers from ‘engag[ing] in the ‘practice of law’ or the ‘law business’ in Tennessee.’ “
  • “The court received almost 400 comments in response to its request, according to the order. Those weighing in included lawyers, law firms, law schools and organizations including the Tennessee Board of Law Examiners, the Tennessee Access to Justice Commission, the Tennessee Bar Association, the Tennessee Attorney General, the Federal Trade Commission, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Tennessee and the Council of the ABA Section of Legal Education and Admissions to the Bar, among others.”
  • “‘From our perspective, the Tennessee order is a positive development,’ Attorneys’ Liability Assurance Society (ALAS) Senior Vice President of Loss Prevention Nesheba Kittling told Law.com in a phone call on Tuesday. ALAS was one of the organizations that submitted public comment to Tennessee’s high court.”
  • “Kittling said that her organization is against private equity involvement in law firm ownership because ‘there are some lawyer liability risks associated with nonlawyer ownership of law firms,’ including ‘a downstream impact on lawyer independence, client service and adherence to the rules of professional conduct.'”
  • “‘As lawyers, we have a unique relationship with our clients where client interests are supposed to supersede anything else, including profits,’ Kittling said. ‘The concern is that [by] introducing nonlawyer ownership, [including private equity], there may be an erosion of that, and there may be pressure to put profits over client interest and client service. For example, that could go to staffing, right? Is there pressure to decrease the amount of lawyers who are on a matter? And then does that decrease mean it impacts the client representation, which ultimately could lead to a malpractice claim?'”

Lawyer/Law Firm Impersonation Risk in the Age of TikTok: “TikTok Lawyers Face Their AI Clones” —

  • “Documented found swarms of fake immigration attorney TikTok accounts and bots targeting immigrants in an analysis of tens of millions of posts.”