
“How hackers broke into four of Canada’s top law firms, stole client files and caused chaos” —
- “One week ago, lawyers at Canada’s top firms received urgent calls from their IT departments about a critical software update or an expired password. The agents were happy to stay on the phone and help. Even to a skeptic, the calls could seem legitimate. They were often placed through Microsoft Teams, appearing to come from internal IT employees, or they were phone calls from the IT department’s number.”
- “The reality: Hackers were on the other end, spamming Canadian lawyers en masse.”
- “The tactic the hackers used is called vishing, short for voice phishing – and it worked. At least four companies were broken into, all among the country’s most prestigious law firms: McCarthy Tétrault LLP, Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLP, Bennett Jones LLP and Borden Ladner Gervais LLP.”
- “The extent of the damage is still being assessed, but the fallout is already immense. Law firms market themselves as trusted advisers, and the nature of their work means they store sensitive files on their servers. These include non-public corporate information, communication between client and counsel, and their clients’ tax, financial or health records.”
- “Because so much sensitive information is potentially exposed – at McCarthy Tétrault, 31,000 files were stolen, according to a source directly involved – some clients are extremely concerned, but so far remain in the dark. Lawyers at the hacked firms have been told which clients were affected, but specific details are often still coming, according to four sources and communication reviewed by The Globe and Mail.”
- “There’s also a fear of more breaches to come. Hackers are increasingly targeting law firms, and the Canadian hack proves even the largest firms with the most sophisticated technology can’t always ward them off. What the top firms spend on hacking defences would likely exceed the annual revenues of scores of smaller boutiques across Canada that specialize in practice areas such as employment and family law.”
- “Across the four firms that were breached, at least seven employees granted the hackers access to internal files, according to The Globe’s reporting and confirmed by the respective firms. McCarthy Tétrault had four employee accounts compromised; Bennett Jones had two; Davies had one. It is unclear how many users were compromised at BLG.”
- “The depth of the breaches varied. At Bennett Jones, the firm’s document management system, used to protect client legal files and work product, was not affected, the firm said Friday. Its accounting system was also unaffected.”
- “‘The compromised information included reports on revenue from clients; for certain clients, general descriptions of our mandates for them were also involved and as we identify those clients, we will contact them directly,’ Bennett Jones said in a statement.”
- “At BLG, an internal investigation confirmed that ‘certain files, including files related to clients, were accessed by an unauthorised third party,’ the firm said Friday in a statement.”
- “On Thursday, McCarthy Tétrault said a third party ‘gained access to certain files, including information relating to clients,’ while Davies said Thursday it identified ‘the compromise of information from one account.’ McCarthy Tétrault was hacked on Oct. 22 and Davies was hacked on Oct. 23.”
- “In Canada, law firms and IT departments are working together to understand how the hackers got access to confidential data, what to do to help clients and how to ensure it doesn’t happen again.”
“The Next Target for Data Breach Lawsuits – Law Firms That Represent Breached Parties” —
- “Imagine a company gets hacked and hires a law firm to manage the response. The lawyers coordinate the forensic investigation, determine which notification laws apply, and advise management about what to disclose and when. Months later, the notices arrive. The affected individuals sue the company and add its lawyers as defendants. Their theory is that counsel helped keep them in the dark when an earlier warning might have allowed them to protect themselves.”
- “In this hypothetical, nobody hacked the law firm. The alleged wrongdoing is the firm’s handling of its client’s breach. That is a materially different claim from the increasingly familiar allegation that a law firm failed to secure personal information on its own systems. It also presents a much harder question about the person to whom the lawyer owed a duty.”
- “Recent litigation makes the distinction particularly important. The proposed class action against Austin-based Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson concerns the firm’s own alleged data breach and failure to provide notice. The case is Lowry v. Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson, LLP, filed October 27, 2026, in the Western District of Texas. It is not evidence that a court has recognized a consumer’s malpractice claim against counsel for a separately breached company.”
- “This is fundamentally different from a lawsuit alleging that the firm itself leaked or breached a duty to protect data it held. For example, Todd Garvin filed a proposed class action against Dill Dill Stonbraker & Hutchings on October 27, 2026. The firm’s public notice describes unauthorized access to information in its own systems during October and November 2025, a June 1, 2026 determination that personal information may have been affected, and an October 22 notice.”
- “The more consequential question is whether plaintiffs can move from suing lawyers as custodians of compromised data to suing them as advisers to the entity that suffered the compromise. There is substantial precedent for the first category. I have not identified a reported merits decision establishing a general duty running from outside breach counsel to every individual affected by the client’s breach merely because counsel advised the client about notification.”
- “A breach-response engagement ordinarily makes the affected company the client. Counsel’s job is to understand the facts, explain the applicable law, recommend a lawful response, and give the client enough information to make informed decisions. Model Rule 1.4 describes that obligation in terms of communication with the client. A customer whose records were stolen does not become a client of the company’s lawyers simply because those lawyers discuss the customer’s information.”
- “Other jurisdictions reach the issue through attorney immunity as well as privity. In Haynes and Boone, LLP v. NFTD, LLC, the Texas Supreme Court held that its attorney-immunity defense can extend to legal work outside litigation in an adversarial setting. The inquiry concerns the kind of work performed, including whether it uses a lawyer’s professional skills in representing the client. The court remanded for application of that standard; it did not declare every act by a lawyer immune. The later appellate decision found that the defendants had not conclusively established the defense on the record presented. Neither decision involved a breach response, but both warn against treating all activity undertaken by a law firm as legally interchangeable.”
- “There are equally important limits on the defense. A firm that receives and stores personal information may incur obligations arising from that conduct. The absence of an attorney-client relationship with the affected individual does not necessarily answer an ordinary data-security claim. A plaintiff must identify the applicable duty, and the firm must address the conduct actually challenged.”
- “The Bryan Cave litigation illustrates the distinction. Employees of Mondelez sued after personal information held by the company’s law firm was exposed in a breach of the firm’s systems. In June 2024, a federal court allowed negligence claims against both the company and the law firm to proceed, reasoning in part from Illinois’s statutory requirement for reasonable data-security measures. The order states: ‘Plaintiffs’ negligence claims survive in both consolidated actions.’ That was a pleading-stage ruling, not a finding of negligence. The litigation subsequently moved into settlement proceedings. It remains a useful example of a claim concerning counsel’s custody of nonclients’ information, rather than a holding that the firm’s legal advice created a professional duty to those nonclients.”
- “Similarly, the law firm of Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP advised Delta Dental beneficiaries that it obtained their information while representing Delta Dental and that files on Orrick’s network were compromised. The firm was sued by the data subjects for breaching their privacy.”
- “What makes the Colorado case different is that the plaintiffs allege that they were harmed because of the advice the law firm gave to their own client, and their client’s following that advice. A different approach might have been for the class action plaintiffs to sue the entity that failed to timely notify them, and then for that company to sue their lawyers for malpractice.”
- “This raises the stakes for both lawyers and data breach subjects – as well as for insurance companies representing both. Law firms may be more reluctant to take on high-stakes breach cases, and it injects a good deal of self-interest into the privileged relationship. For plaintiffs, the serious question is whether counsel assumed or violated a legally recognized obligation to the affected individual. For defense counsel, the serious question is whether the challenged act was legal representation, data handling, or a separate undertaking. Linebarger’s own alleged breach belongs in that analysis as a comparison, not as proof that breach advisers owe a malpractice duty to their clients’ customers. The next complaint may name the breach coach. It will still have to explain why that coach owed this plaintiff a duty.”
“New York State Bar Association Releases In-Depth Guidelines To Advise Attorneys on Ethical Use of AI” —
- “Guidelines on artificial intelligence approved by the New York State Bar Association will help avoid the unauthorized practice of law, ensure that legal decisions are in human hands, and reduce bias in legal proceedings.”
- “On Saturday, the New York State Bar Association’s governing body, the House of Delegates, adopted the report ‘Legal Ethics Guidelines for Lawyers’ Use of Artificial Intelligence.'”
- “‘Generative AI is indelibly changing the practice of law. As part of our mission to be the leading voice for the legal profession, we are providing clear guidelines on the use of AI tools as a resource so attorneys can use AI responsibly and ethically in their practices,’ said Taa Grays, president of the New York State Bar Association. ‘The guidelines can help attorneys avoid possible perils of using AI including inadvertently practicing law in a jurisdiction where they are not licensed or failing to notify clients or the courts of AI use.'”
- “The association is urging attorneys who use AI tools to check that the results do not reflect biased input from training data, design and deployment. There is concern that an AI can replicate already-existing systemic inequities – like if its training material uses sentencing information with racial disparities. This is especially relevant if the tool is being used in a way that could affect a person’s rights, access, opportunity, or treatment.”
- “The report also advises attorneys who use AI that they may charge fees for time spent verifying an AI tool’s output, but not for learning how to use it. It is important to keep fees reasonable and disclose specific charges to clients. In addition, acquiring an AI tool is an overhead expense – so its cost may not be billed to a client, unless it is for a service specially incurred for that case.”
- “Attorneys are also responsible for carefully supervising non-lawyers and vendors who use AI tools. While the New York Rules of Professional Conduct do not specifically address AI-generated legal work, association guidelines extrapolate that an attorney is still responsible for ensuring that a non-lawyer’s work is up to standards – even if the ‘non-lawyer’ is an AI tool or system.”
- “The report also covers:”
- “Conflicts of interest from a tool using data that pertains to a party in a case.”
- “Notifying all parties when using AI for recording and summaries.”
- “Disclosing the use of AI for court submissions – a policy many courts already have in place.”
- Reviewing the output of agentic AI systems – tools that are designed to complete a task or accomplish a specific goal without human input.”
- “Vivian Wesson, executive vice president, general counsel, and chief compliance officer of The Board of Pensions of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), serves as chair of the Committee on Artificial Intelligence and Emerging Technologies, which authored the report.”
- “‘While technology keeps evolving, it is important to still follow the ethical principles of the law,’ said Wesson. ‘Our committee developed this report to aid attorneys who are using AI tools and systems to enhance their practices. We aim to help lawyers utilize the technology while fulfilling their responsibility to their clients, the courts, and the administration of justice.'”
- Document (including its AI-generated cover image) available: here.
“Lawyers offer recommendations on proposed AI ethics opinion” —
- “A Florida Bar committee’s proposed advisory opinion regarding artificial intelligence is generating suggestions from a handful of attorneys, most of whom are eager for more guidance.”
- “Although a draft is not yet available, the notice advised that it may cover lawyers’ use of agentic AI tools; the use of artificial intelligence tools to record, transcribe, and summarize communications; guidance to clients regarding their use of artificial intelligence tools; and updates to guidance provided in Florida Ethics Opinion 24-1.”
- “Gainesville lawyer Nathan Nevins, one of eight attorneys who submitted comments as of November 3, is the only commenter opposed to most lawyers’ use of the technology. A partner with Sunshine State Probate, Nevins is board certified in wills, trusts and estates. He was admitted to the Bar in 2013.”
- “AI use by attorneys for anything other than legal research should be ‘wholly banned,’ Nevins recommends, adding that even then, the research results should be ‘double checked by each attorney.'”
- “Attorneys are forwarding AI-generated proposals to their opponents and getting back AI-generated responses or counter proposals, Nevins warns.”
- “‘We literally have scenarios now where we have AI negotiating contracts with other AI,’ Nevins wrote. ‘This is what we want the legal profession to turn into?'”
- “Ryan Enage, a civil trial lawyer with Lloyd & McDaniel and a Florida Bar member since 2022, notes that the Florida Supreme Court this summer amended Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.515(d)(2)(Representation by Signer). The amendments state that by filing, the signer of a document represents that ‘the legal authorities identified exist and are accurately cited.'”
- “The Supreme Court order noted that while AI tools can be helpful, they also can generate content that appears plausible but is in fact inaccurate, including fabricated or ‘hallucinated’ authorities, Enage notes. He also notes that Florida judges in 2000 recommended that pleadings prepared by an attorney and filed on behalf of a pro-se litigant indicate ‘Prepared with the Assistance of Counsel.'”
- “He recommends that ‘pleadings or other papers in which artificial intelligence was used in their preparation and filed with the court, both prepared by attorneys and prepared by unrepresented parties…indicate ‘Prepared with Assistance of Artificial Intelligence.’'”
- “Hialeah attorney Arianna Mendez, a Florida Bar member since 2020, says her practice focuses mostly on commercial litigation, business transactions, and real estate disputes.”
- “‘In my practice, clients have brought me AI-generated legal advice and have shared sensitive information with AI tools,’ Mendez writes. ‘These experiences have raised concerns for me about the discovery implications of clients’ independent use of AI: what records they are creating, what information they are disclosing, and what may need to be preserved.'”
- “Clients may be mistakenly viewing their use of AI as a ‘private exchange,’ she writes.”
- “‘I would welcome guidance on how lawyers should counsel clients about these risks, including potential requests for prompts, uploaded materials, and responses.'”
- “Once a draft is proposed, it will be noticed in the News prior to consideration by the Board of Governors.”